I got all the keys at Afterlands and have every lock unlocked except for the top one. Adler's White Key remains in my inventory, but when I click on that top white lock it tells me "It looks like you don't have the key for that particular lock."
I got the same problem. I switch between night and day several times. After each switch, I went back to the door and started spam clicking...which magically worked.
Comments
Seriously, why are these old bugs never fixed??
If anyone else has it, try clicking on the TOP part of the lock. That might help.